Educators are slowly making the transition from education professional to civil service grunt. Society learned long ago of self-fulfilling prophecies. Treating someone a certain way for a long enough period of time, will cause them to behave that way. Intellectuals don’t function within that same realm, however there are exceptions to every rule.
Treating someone badly for a prolonged period of time and then expecting them to yield positive results is just ludicrous. It’s just that simple. Value someone as a person, and they will offer a human response.
Educators are no longer valued as the noble professionals they once were. In history, similar trends have occurred and society has evolved or even recovered. But the pendellum is not swinging back quickly enough.
Working to the contract, signing in/out for lunches, documenting all interpersonal interactions…these are things that clerical and and “nine to five employees” do daily to justify their jobs. It’s menial yet measurable.
But educators are held to a higher standard. All the while the measuring stick becomes more and more antiquated. How can any professional gain a semblance of distinction when the standards are constantly changing?
There isn’t a single educator who chose their profession because of a secret desire to crunch numbers, process paperwork, or punch a clock.
Educators have been the focus of political blame because they are an easy target. The cost of education is a constant. As long as there are students, there will be teachable content and an opportunity to build on previous knowledge.
And the cost of THIS is immeasurable.
School districts, municipal boards, county and state budget committees struggle annually to project for these increasing costs. So where do they cut? Anywhere and everywhere!
No matter where the cuts occur, human lives are impacted. The teacher-to-student bond will be dimished to a point that it can no longer exist. Cyber schools are no longer science fiction and lore. The movement to eliminate teachers has begun. Students will “develop” without instruction. And those teachers WILL become the statisticians and programmers of online content accessible only through a internet server.
The biggest expense in education is the cost of the teacher. The second biggest expense is the student. Third is the cost of replenishing, upgrading, and maintaining the educational infrustructure. But the infrustructure has value beyond the classroom. When the classrooms are no longer sufficient, they will be used for something else. Public school buildings built today are designed to serve multiple purposes (as they always have been). Today it’s a public school; tomorrow it’s a charter school; five years from now a church; eventually a bomb shelter.
But aren’t educators like other civil servants?
No! They are less effective in negotiating their own work environment. The controls over their work environment are in the hands of school boards and the public by proxy.
Educators can’t apply the effective labor tactics that other unions employ. They can’t strike. They can’t really speak to the media without recourse, and their online activity is monitored closely. No matter how badly they’re bullied, educators remain resilient.
Holding their heads high, educators generate lesson plan, grade assessments between classes, coordinate with cohorts, develop professionally, convention collectively, and some even lobby through their associations to create positive change–all on their own time.
By policy makers, school boards, administrators, parents, and sometimes students, educators succum to the demands beyond their control. They’re not easily persuaded though. Educators are dignified and diligent. An unmoving target, the blows are met with great force.
But isn’t education changing?
Education evolves, but at a steady (and sometimes slower) rate than other aspects of society. Ed policy is based on data-based studies and proven success. This takes time. But in recent years, data is driven by the need to be more efficient regardless of how effective. Not to mention that the resources, tools, curriculum, and texts used in the classroom are marketed by for-profit entities tied to political policy. Non-educators making Ed policy?
Educators hold themselves to a higher standard already. Educators persevere. They thrive on the teachable moments in every lesson. Life lessons are built on overcoming adversity. Educators turn negatives into positives daily. So it’s really no surprise that educators are willing to tolerate, flex, and bend to accommodate the circumstances. A steady target!
The politicians may never know the wrath of this type of public servant. Educators can take abuse and never reach their breaking point. Dealing with parents, negotiating with administrators, encouraging students to reach their potential. It’s not easy work. The most experienced educator perseveres through the most challenging circumstances. And upon retirement, educators continue to nurture!
How many other professions can make that claim. Educators just don’t quit. So putting the entire profession into a vice and squeezing is not going to end in a positive manner. But the students will learning. The students are watching. What lesson is being taught?
Consider all of these factors (and knowing that more and more obstacles are mounting). To be any less would negate the silent oath of an educator. To work less, to care less, to plan less, advocate less…would simply ease our transitions becoming civil service grunts. Educators would be as effective as any other civil servant, but with more power. More power to secure our community—or all the ability to simply walk away.